# Test Review Report: {PROJECT_NAME} **Review Date**: {DATE} **Reviewer**: {REVIEWER} **Period Covered**: {START_DATE} to {END_DATE} --- ## Executive Summary ### Overall Health: {Good | Needs Work | Critical} ### Key Findings 1. {Finding 1} 2. {Finding 2} 3. {Finding 3} ### Recommended Actions 1. {High priority action} 2. {Medium priority action} 3. {Ongoing improvement} --- ## Test Suite Metrics ### Test Distribution | Type | Count | % of Total | | -------------------- | ----- | ---------- | | Unit Tests | | | | Integration Tests | | | | Play Mode/Functional | | | | Performance Tests | | | | **Total** | | 100% | ### Execution Metrics | Metric | Current | Previous | Trend | | -------------- | ------- | -------- | ----- | | Pass Rate | | | {↑↓→} | | Avg Duration | | | {↑↓→} | | Flaky Tests | | | {↑↓→} | | Disabled Tests | | | {↑↓→} | ### Recent Run History | Date | Passed | Failed | Skipped | Duration | | ---- | ------ | ------ | ------- | -------- | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | --- ## Quality Assessment ### Strengths - {What the test suite does well} - {Good patterns observed} - {Areas of strong coverage} ### Issues Found | Issue | Severity | Count | Example | Recommended Fix | | ------------------ | -------- | ----- | ------- | --------------- | | Flaky tests | High | | | | | Slow tests | Medium | | | | | Missing cleanup | Medium | | | | | Hard-coded waits | Low | | | | | Unclear assertions | Low | | | | ### Anti-Patterns Detected | Pattern | Occurrences | Impact | Fix Effort | | --------- | ----------- | ------ | ---------- | | {pattern} | | | | --- ## Coverage Analysis ### Feature Coverage Matrix | Feature | P0 Tests | P1 Tests | P2 Tests | Gap? | | ------------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ---- | | Core Loop | | | | | | Combat/Action | | | | | | Movement | | | | | | UI/Menus | | | | | | Save/Load | | | | | | Progression | | | | | | Multiplayer | | | | | | Audio | | | | | | Platform | | | | | ### Critical Gaps | Gap | Risk | Impact | Priority to Fix | | ----------------------- | ------------ | ----------- | --------------- | | {feature without tests} | {risk level} | {if breaks} | P{0-3} | ### Coverage by Priority ``` P0 Coverage: {X}% ████████░░ P1 Coverage: {X}% ██████░░░░ P2 Coverage: {X}% ████░░░░░░ P3 Coverage: {X}% ██░░░░░░░░ ``` --- ## Infrastructure Review ### CI/CD Integration | Aspect | Status | Notes | | ----------------- | ------- | ----- | | Tests in CI | {✅/❌} | | | Results visible | {✅/❌} | | | Failures block | {✅/❌} | | | Nightly runs | {✅/❌} | | | Performance tests | {✅/❌} | | ### Test Infrastructure Quality | Component | Quality | Notes | | -------------- | ---------------- | ----- | | Fixtures | {Good/Fair/Poor} | | | Helpers | {Good/Fair/Poor} | | | Data factories | {Good/Fair/Poor} | | | Documentation | {Good/Fair/Poor} | | ### Maintenance Burden - Test update frequency: {high/medium/low} - Brittleness score: {high/medium/low} - Developer friction: {high/medium/low} --- ## Recommendations ### Immediate (This Sprint) | Action | Effort | Impact | Owner | | ------------------------- | ------- | ------ | ----- | | {fix critical flaky test} | {hours} | High | | | {add P0 test for X} | {hours} | High | | ### Short-term (This Milestone) | Action | Effort | Impact | Owner | | ----------------------------- | ------ | ------ | ----- | | {refactor slow tests} | {days} | Medium | | | {add integration tests for Y} | {days} | Medium | | ### Long-term (Ongoing) | Action | Effort | Impact | Notes | | ----------------------------- | ------- | ------ | ----- | | {improve test infrastructure} | {weeks} | High | | | {expand coverage to Z} | {weeks} | Medium | | --- ## Appendices ### Appendix A: Flaky Tests | Test Name | Failure Rate | Failure Pattern | Fix Priority | | --------- | ------------ | --------------- | ------------ | | | | | | ### Appendix B: Slow Tests | Test Name | Duration | Type | Action | | --------- | -------- | ---- | -------------------------- | | | | | {optimize/move to nightly} | ### Appendix C: Disabled Tests | Test Name | Disabled Since | Reason | Action | | --------- | -------------- | ------ | ------------ | | | | | {fix/delete} | ### Appendix D: Technical Debt | Item | Description | Effort | Priority | | ---- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | | | | | | --- ## Next Review **Scheduled**: {DATE} **Focus Areas**: {areas to pay attention to} **Success Criteria**: {what would make next review "green"}